TL;DR
- You usually stay covered. HealthCare.gov says that if you have Marketplace coverage in December and don't pick a plan or stop coverage by December 15, you'll be automatically re-enrolled for January 1.
- It may not be the plan you have now. It can be a different plan from your insurer, or a comparable plan from another company if yours stops selling.
- Prices can change. HealthCare.gov says costs can change even when you are automatically re-enrolled.
- Your tax credit may be based on old income. If you don't update your application, the Marketplace may use the most recent income information it has, per CMS.
- The cost of a wrong estimate went up: The IRS says there is no repayment cap on excess advance premium tax credits for tax years after 2025.
If you already have a Marketplace plan, you might wonder whether you can just let it renew. For many people the answer is yes, and it keeps you from a gap in coverage. But "do nothing" has more moving parts than it did a few years ago, especially around how your tax credit is calculated. This guide explains what happens at each step if you skip Open Enrollment, what you can still change afterward, and where the financial risk sits.
What Happens If You Do Nothing
On HealthCare.gov, the answer comes from the page on automatic re-enrollment. It says that during Open Enrollment, which runs November 1 to January 15, if you have Marketplace coverage you'll be automatically re-enrolled in a plan for next year so you avoid a gap in coverage. You'll get a letter saying whether it's the same plan or a different one. Our guide on how to read your Marketplace renewal letters shows what to check in it.
| If you do nothing, and... | What HealthCare.gov says happens |
|---|
| Your plan is still available | You are re-enrolled for January 1. Costs can still change. |
| Your insurer changed or ended the plan | You may be re-enrolled in a different plan with the same company. |
| Your insurer has no similar plan | You are re-enrolled in a comparable plan from a different company. |
| You want no Marketplace coverage next year | You must stop the re-enrollment yourself, or you'll be re-enrolled. |
HealthCare.gov also says an insurance company can't move you to a different plan based on your health or how much care you use.
Why "Do Nothing" Can Cost More Than It Looks
1. The Price Can Move
HealthCare.gov says that even if you're automatically re-enrolled, plan costs can change. Benchmark Silver premiums rose 13% on average for 2027, which our post on 2027 ACA premium increases explains. Your monthly bill after tax credit depends on both the plan's price and your credit.
2. Your Credit May Rest on Old Income
Marketplace savings are based on your expected income for the year you're applying for, not past years, HealthCare.gov says. It warns that if you don't update your income and household information, you could qualify for more savings than you're getting or for less, in which case you may have to pay back the difference at tax time.
CMS's material for enrollment assisters, Marketplace Open Enrollment Notices and Re-enrollment, gives two more details. First, if you don't update your application by December 15, the Marketplace may use the most recent income information available to work out your credit. Second, some people can lose their advance credit entirely, namely those who did not authorize the Marketplace to check IRS data, or who were automatically re-enrolled for the past two coverage years and have no recent IRS data on file.
3. A Wrong Estimate Now Has No Safety Net
This is the biggest change. When you file your taxes, you reconcile the advance credit you received against the credit you actually qualify for (the IRS uses Form 8962 for this). If you received too much, you repay the difference. The IRS's Premium Tax Credit Q&As (updated December 23, 2025) explain that for tax years before 2026, a repayment cap could limit what you owe if your household income was under 400% of the federal poverty level. The IRS now states: "There is no repayment cap for tax years after 2025."
That means for 2026 and later, an advance credit based on income that is too low can leave you owing the whole excess. Our ACA income limits page and APTC calculator help you check where your expected income falls.
Hypothetical: Old Income, New Bill
Hypothetical example (not a real person). Sky gets an advance credit of $400 a month based on last year's income. Sky does nothing in Open Enrollment, then earns more than expected during the year.
- Advance credits received: $400 × 12 = $4,800.
- Credit Sky actually qualifies for on the final return: $3,000.
- Excess to repay: $4,800 − $3,000 = $1,800. With no repayment cap for tax years after 2025, Sky's repayment is not limited to a smaller amount.
*Illustrative numbers only. Your credit depends on your income, household size, location, and plan. Check with HealthCare.gov, a tax professional, or a licensed agent.
What You Can Still Do After You're Auto-Renewed
Being automatically re-enrolled isn't final. According to HealthCare.gov:
- How you'll know: You'll get a letter from the Marketplace. When you log in on or after December 16, you may also see a message on your "My Plans & Programs" page.
- Change plans by December 15 if you want your new plan to start January 1.
- Change plans by January 15 if you've already been auto-enrolled. A plan you pick then starts February 1, and you must pay your first premium for coverage to start.
- After January 15, you can change plans only with a Special Enrollment Period.
How to Stop an Automatic Re-Enrollment
If you don't want Marketplace coverage next year, you have to act. HealthCare.gov lists these steps to cancel your re-enrollment, to be completed by December 15:
- Log in to your Marketplace account.
- Select your current year application, not next year's.
- On the "My Plans & Programs" page, select the stop coverage button.
If you were already auto-enrolled and don't want coverage, HealthCare.gov says to log in by December 31 to stop it from starting. Before you do, think about what going without coverage could cost you, and whether you may have to wait for the next Open Enrollment to enroll again. Our post on paying your first premium explains the rules for when coverage starts and what happens when payments stop.
A Checklist Before You Let It Renew
- Read both letters to see which plan you're matched with and its price.
- Log in and update your 2027 income and household details, even if you think nothing changed.
- Compare the matched plan with others on total yearly cost: 12 months of premiums plus the deductible and copays you expect to pay. See how to compare health insurance plans.
- Check your doctors and prescriptions against the 2027 network and drug list.
- Decide by December 15. If you choose to do nothing, do it on purpose.
Conclusion
Doing nothing in Open Enrollment usually keeps you covered, since HealthCare.gov re-enrolls current enrollees on January 1. But the plan can differ, the price can change, and your tax credit may rest on income that is out of date. Because the IRS says there is no repayment cap for tax years after 2025, a wrong estimate can now cost you more at tax time. A few minutes updating your application before December 15 is the cheapest protection. If your situation is complicated, check with HealthCare.gov, your state exchange, a tax professional, or a licensed agent.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Will my Marketplace plan renew automatically if I do nothing?
Usually, yes. HealthCare.gov says it will automatically re-enroll you if you have Marketplace coverage in December and don't pick a plan or stop your coverage by December 15. You get a letter saying whether it's the same plan or a different one. - Can I change plans after I'm automatically re-enrolled?
Yes. To start a new plan January 1, enroll by December 15. If your automatic re-enrollment coverage has started, you can still change plans until January 15, when Open Enrollment ends. A plan chosen then starts February 1, and you must pay your first premium. - What if I don't want coverage next year?
You must act. HealthCare.gov says to log in by December 15, select your current year application, and use the stop coverage button on the "My Plans & Programs" page. If you were already auto-enrolled, log in by December 31 to stop coverage from starting. - What happens to my tax credit if I don't update my application?
CMS says that if you don't update your application by December 15, the Marketplace may use the most recent income information available to determine your credit. If your advance credit is more than you qualify for, you repay the difference when you file taxes. - Is there a cap on how much of an excess tax credit I have to repay?
For tax years after 2025, no. The IRS states that there is no repayment cap for tax years after 2025. Estimate what you may owe with our premium tax credit repayment calculator, then confirm with a tax professional.
Check Your 2027 Options Before December 15
PolicyMage shows the total yearly cost of each plan after your estimated tax credit, so you can compare your matched plan with the alternatives.
Compare Marketplace Plans →